WCAG
WCAG Conformance Levels A, AA, and AAA—and Which Level the BFSG Requires
Contents
The WCAG define three conformance levels: A, AA, and AAA. In practice, the underlying question is usually the same—which level do I need? The short answer for the BFSG is Level AA. This article explains what the three levels mean, why AA is the relevant standard, and how conformance is determined.
What the conformance levels mean
The three levels build on one another: A is the lowest, AA is the middle, and AAA is the highest. Each higher level includes the criteria of the levels below it. AA therefore includes all Level A criteria plus the additional Level AA criteria, while AAA includes all of those plus the Level AAA criteria.
These are not freely selectable “grades,” but categories indicating how extensively accessibility barriers are addressed. Every WCAG success criterion is assigned to exactly one level. For a complete explanation of the WCAG and how they are structured, see the WCAG Guide.
Level A—the minimum
Level A addresses the most fundamental accessibility barriers. Without meeting these requirements, content may be completely unusable for certain groups. Examples include text alternatives for images, keyboard access to essential functionality, avoiding dangerously flashing content, and identifying the page’s language.
Level A alone is not legally sufficient—it is the minimum foundation, not the goal.
Level AA—the standard
AA is the level required by laws worldwide, including the BFSG, because it addresses the most important accessibility barriers encountered in practice. Typical Level AA requirements include sufficient colour contrast, resizable text, consistent navigation, clear labels, and understandable error messages.
AA is also a realistic and achievable target for a genuine website. For a detailed explanation of one specific AA requirement, see WCAG Colour Contrast. The BFSG Checklist provides a practical list of requirements to assess.
Level AAA—the highest level
AAA imposes the strictest requirements, such as a contrast ratio of 7:1, sign-language interpretation for videos, and particularly strict rules for understandability and time limits. The W3C itself notes that it is not possible to satisfy all Level AAA success criteria for some types of content and explicitly recommends that AAA should not be required as a general policy for entire websites.
AAA is therefore worth pursuing selectively in specific areas, but it is not a realistic universal requirement. This is precisely why legislation does not generally require Level AAA.
Which level the BFSG requires
The relevant standard is Level AA. The BFSG refers to the harmonised standard EN 301 549, whose currently applicable version, v3.2.1, references WCAG 2.1 Level AA. Learn more in EN 301 549 Explained.
WCAG 2.2 Level AA is the recommended best practice and is expected to become the future standard. The upcoming version of EN 301 549, v4.1.1, expected to be published in 2026, is anticipated to incorporate it. At present, however, WCAG 2.1 Level AA remains the legally binding baseline.
One important final point: meeting WCAG 2.1 Level AA is necessary, but it does not by itself guarantee full BFSG compliance because EN 301 549 includes requirements beyond the WCAG. For the wider legal framework, see the BFSG Guide.
How conformance is determined
Two points are essential. First, conformance is assessed on a page-by-page basis, and a complete process—such as a checkout journey—must remain conformant throughout, not only on the homepage. Second, each level follows an all-or-nothing principle: to claim Level AA conformance, a page must satisfy all Level A and AA success criteria. There is no such thing as being “80% AA conformant.” A single unmet Level AA criterion means the page is not AA conformant.
This is also why automated “scores” can be misleading: a high percentage is not proof of conformance. See Accessibility Testing to learn how conformance can be assessed reliably.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which WCAG level do I need for the BFSG?
Level AA—through the EN 301 549 v3.2.1 standard, which references WCAG 2.1 Level AA.
Should I aim for Level AAA immediately?
Generally, not across the entire website. The W3C advises against requiring AAA as a blanket standard for a whole website because it cannot be achieved for every type of content. AA is the appropriate target, although individual AAA criteria may be useful in specific areas.
Is it enough to meet most Level AA criteria?
No. Conformance at each level is all or nothing. A single unmet Level AA criterion means that the page cannot be considered AA conformant.
Updated: . This article gives a general overview. Not legal advice.